I was able to find a very handy past All-American list on the Cyclones and I went all the way back to 2002. The significance of that year would be the last time Iowa State had an All-American at every weight. In other words, every weight has had an All-American for Iowa State except 149, where you have to go all the way back to 2002 to find Billy Maldonado.
You missed one. Luke Lofthouse, 2011, 5th place, 197lbs.
That’s why I got you to keep me honest!