Wartburg leads the way with five on the 1st team and an additional wrestler making the 2nd team. Coe features three wrestlers earning 1st team honors, with Luther grabbing the last two spots on the 1st team.
| 1st Team | ||
| Name | School | |
| 125 | Jan Rosenburg | Coe |
| 133 | Connor Campo | Wartburg |
| 141 | Drew Van Anrooy | Luther |
| 149 | Kenny Martin | Wartburg |
| 157 | Drew Wagenhoffer | Wartburg |
| 165 | Farai Sewera | Coe |
| 174 | Ryan Harrington | Coe |
| 184 | Justin Kreiter | Luther |
| 197 | Gerard Roman | Wartburg |
| 285 | Ben Nagle | Wartburg |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Name | School | |
| 125 | Scott Smith | Cornell |
| 133 | Nathan Shank | Cornell |
| 141 | Nick Steger | Loras |
| 149 | Trevor Engle | Cornell |
| 157 | Reed Van Anrooy | Luther |
| 165 | Andrew Steiert | Wartburg |
| 174 | Elton Turnage | Dubuque |
| 184 | Spencer Ward | Simpson |
| 197 | Matt Seabold | Central |
| 285 | Conner Herman | Luther |